Articles, notes, and symposia pieces published in CLR’s print volumes.

Print Edition

Volume 112, October 2024, Anna VanCleave, Article California Law Review Volume 112, October 2024, Anna VanCleave, Article California Law Review

Prison Banking

This Article examines the history and legal status of inmate trust accounts and the vulnerability of these funds. The Article places prison banking within the broader landscape of racialized wealth extraction through the criminal system and challenges the assumption that prisons and jails—subject to little regulation despite apparent conflicts of interest—should be permitted to operate a low-transparency banking system with exclusive control.

Read More
Volume 112, October 2024, Mark Bartholomew, Article California Law Review Volume 112, October 2024, Mark Bartholomew, Article California Law Review

A Right to Be Left Dead

This Article interrogates the need for a right to be left dead and takes some preliminary steps towards defining its contours, chief among them an awareness that an individual right to prevent unauthorized reanimations of the dead must look very different than the existing privacy, consumer protection, and property laws marshalled against unauthorized invocations of the living.

Read More
Volume 112, October 2024, Annie Brett, Article California Law Review Volume 112, October 2024, Annie Brett, Article California Law Review

Rethinking Environmental Disclosure

Despite the widespread enthusiasm, after decades of implementation it is increasingly clear that information regulation largely fails to achieve its environmental goals. This Article makes two main contributions. By drawing on quantitative and qualitative case studies of information-forcing regulations, it first answers the question of whether this approach to environmental regulation is effective. This Article then analyzes the mechanisms behind information forcing in conjunction with these case studies to propose characteristics that determine the success, or failure, of information regulation.

Read More
Volume 112, August 2024, Sara A. Colangelo, Article California Law Review Volume 112, August 2024, Sara A. Colangelo, Article California Law Review

Bridging Silos: Environmental and Reproductive Justice in the Climate Crisis

This Article makes two interventions into existing legal scholarship. First, the Article identifies an intersectional nexus of hazard between environmental and reproductive justice, which is especially acute for women of color living in under-resourced communities. Second, the Article argues for a ground-up approach based on community power-building and interdisciplinary cooperation, which can inform legal and policy solutions at scale.

Read More
Volume 112, August 2024, Aliza H. Bloom, Article California Law Review Volume 112, August 2024, Aliza H. Bloom, Article California Law Review

Whack-A-Mole Reasonable Suspicion

This Article examines police officers’ and deferential courts’ emerging reliance on the term “blading” or “blading away,” as a behavior supporting the reasonable suspicion constitutionally required for a stop and search. After conducting a comprehensive analysis of the term’s usage in state and federal courts over the past five years, the Article groups three contradictory categories of meaning and argues for the abolition of "blading" as a justification.

Read More
Volume 112, June 2024, Article, Emmanuel Mauleon California Law Review Volume 112, June 2024, Article, Emmanuel Mauleon California Law Review

Legal Endearment: An Unmarked Barrier to Transforming Policing, Public Safety, and Security

The problems of racialized policing have come into renewed focus over the past decade. Even after the mobilization of one of the largest racial justice movements in American history, transformative change remains elusive. This Article offers an answer to this puzzle by foregrounding White people’s collective relationship with policing and describing how this relationship colors current debates on how to best address policing’s racial disparities.

Read More
Volume 112, April 2024, Article, Yvette Butler California Law Review Volume 112, April 2024, Article, Yvette Butler California Law Review

Survival Labor

This Article makes one simple, novel claim: crime is labor when it generates income, allows individuals to pursue self-sufficiency, or allows them to fulfill societal expectations of providing for or caring for dependents. When individuals engage in survival crimes, instead of seeing them as criminals, we should see them as workers engaged in survival labor.

Read More
Article, Volume 112, April 2024, Tejas N. Narechania California Law Review Article, Volume 112, April 2024, Tejas N. Narechania California Law Review

Forum Crowding

Jurists and scholars have long debated (and often decried) the practice of forum shopping. Such debates have overlooked the effects of forum shopping on an important constituency: litigants who have little choice over forum. When forum shopping causes a sudden influx of cases—when, that is, it crowds a forum—what happens to other cases that have nowhere else to go?

Read More
Volume 112, April 2024, Tanner Lockhead, Article California Law Review Volume 112, April 2024, Tanner Lockhead, Article California Law Review

Redistricting Immunity

Redistricting litigation has entered a new era. In 2020, for the first time, state legislatures completed post-census redistricting without preclearance under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA). After Shelby County v. Holder, plaintiffs challenging unlawful maps must rely upon private litigation alone. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court has resuscitated the Purcell Principle, an equitable election law doctrine that prohibits federal courts from changing election rules on the eve of a political contest.

Read More
Volume 112, April 2024, Article, Laura Lane-Steele California Law Review Volume 112, April 2024, Article, Laura Lane-Steele California Law Review

Sex-Defining Laws and Equal Protection

Many equal protection challenges to the recent onslaught of anti-transgender legislation ask courts to determine the constitutional limits of the state’s ability to define sex. The canonical cases addressed the state’s ability to treat men differently from women—not the state’s ability to define “men” and “women.” This difference between the canonical cases and what this Article calls “sex-defining” cases does not necessitate any monumental shifts in equal protection doctrine, but it does require courts to tweak their intermediate scrutiny analyses.

Read More
Volume 112, April 2024, Article, Scott Cummings California Law Review Volume 112, April 2024, Article, Scott Cummings California Law Review

Lawyers in Backsliding Democracy

This Article explores the role of lawyers in democratic backsliding—the degradation of democratic institutions and practices using law rather than violence. The Article’s central aim is to set an agenda and outline an approach to studying the professional paradox at the center of backsliding: why and how lawyers attack the rule of law. It thus seeks to shift the scholarly lens from the conventional view of lawyers as defenders of democracy to investigate lawyers as authors of autocracy.

Read More
Article, Volume 112, February 2024, Jonathan F. Harris California Law Review Article, Volume 112, February 2024, Jonathan F. Harris California Law Review

Consumer Law as Work Law

In recent decades, the U.S. labor market has shifted to more contingent work or work disguised as entrepreneurship. These attenuated relations between worker and firm reflect the “fissuring” of work. Some firms now go beyond fissuring work: they treat the workers themselves as consumers by offering them services and credit products. And when firms expand employment contracts to extend services and credit products to workers, workers are entitled to consumer law protections.

Read More
Article, Volume 112, February 2024, Lauren van Schilfgaarde California Law Review Article, Volume 112, February 2024, Lauren van Schilfgaarde California Law Review

Restorative Justice as Regenerative Tribal Jurisdiction

For more than a century, the United States has sought to restrict Tribal governments’ powers over criminal law. Tribes are increasingly embracing Indigenous-based restorative justice models, which have regenerated Tribal jurisdiction and enhanced the well-being of Tribal members.

Read More
Article, Volume 112, February 2024, Andrea Roth California Law Review Article, Volume 112, February 2024, Andrea Roth California Law Review

The Embarrassing Sixth Amendment

In his 1989 essay The Embarrassing Second Amendment, Sanford Levinson suggested that left-leaning scholars avoid studying the Second Amendment because they are embarrassed that its text might mean what gun-rights proponents claim it means—an individual right to bear arms. Levinson urged such scholars to better engage the text, both to model intellectual integrity and to avoid unnecessarily ceding the terms of a critical constitutional debate. This Article makes a similar argument with respect to the right to counsel granted by the Sixth Amendment.

Read More