Articles, notes, and symposia pieces published in CLR’s print volumes.

Print Edition

Volume 113, February 2025, L. Alexander Walker III, Article California Law Review Volume 113, February 2025, L. Alexander Walker III, Article California Law Review

Black English for Lawyers: A Primer

Lawyers do not know as much about Black English as they should, and people’s freedom hangs in the balance. Differences between language varieties in sounds and grammar can change and have changed the outcome of cases: “He at work” and “He be at work” mean two completely different things. To reduce misinterpretation and therefore wrongful outcomes, this Article provides a primer on the sounds, words, grammar, and social context of Black English targeted directly at legal practitioners. It begins by explaining key concepts in linguistics and making the case for why lawyers must foreground accurate description over normative prescription when facing nonstandard language.

Read More
Volume 113, February 2025, Brian DeLay, Article California Law Review Volume 113, February 2025, Brian DeLay, Article California Law Review

The Myth of Continuity in American Gun Culture

The Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen elevated history, text, and tradition as the sole criteria for assessing the constitutionality of firearms restrictions. Gun rights advocates have responded to Bruen with a wave of Second Amendment challenges, most employing a three-part argument: (1) X firearms-related issue has existed since the Founding; (2) the Founders did little or nothing about it; and, therefore, (3) we cannot do anything about it, either. Legal scholars are engaged in critical work on parts (2) and (3) of that argument. As a professional historian involved in several ongoing Second Amendment cases, I have the disciplinary expertise to offer a critique of part (1). This Article explains why the argument for continuity in American gun culture is largely a myth and offers a case study of the role that historical research can play in Second Amendment cases in the Bruen era.

Read More
Volume 113, Genevieve Lakier, Evelyn Douek, February 2025, Article California Law Review Volume 113, Genevieve Lakier, Evelyn Douek, February 2025, Article California Law Review

The First Amendment Problem of Stalking: Counterman, Stevens, and the Limits of History and Tradition

In Counterman v. Colorado, the Supreme Court decided an imaginary case. It held that Billy Ray Counterman’s conviction could not stand because it did not meet the First Amendment requirements for prosecutions based on threats. But, in fact, Counterman was not convicted for making threats. He was convicted of stalking, under a law that does not require that the defendant threaten anyone to be guilty of the crime. This Article argues that the Supreme Court’s confusion about the most basic facts of the Counterman case was not an aberration but instead reflects broader pathologies in First Amendment jurisprudence.

Read More
Volume 113, February 2025, Hannah Trumbull, Note California Law Review Volume 113, February 2025, Hannah Trumbull, Note California Law Review

Engulfed in Flames: Palliative Strategies for Prison Climate Adaptation

From Hurricane Katrina to the 2021 West Coast wildfires, recent history shows that prisons are unprepared for natural disasters. As a result, incarcerated people experience smoke-filled cells, toxic flooding, and abandonment in unplanned evacuations. Climate change is accelerating the occurrence of natural disasters, creating pressing issues for modern prison infrastructure. Previous scholarship has explored systemic solutions to the issue of prison climate adaptation, such as climate change mitigation and decreasing prison populations. However, long-term solutions fail to address the immediacy of climate emergencies, which affect prisons now. Incarcerated people trapped in the path of today’s floods and fires need short-term solutions while systemic efforts develop.

Read More
Volume 113, February 2025, Julia Wang, Note California Law Review Volume 113, February 2025, Julia Wang, Note California Law Review

Equal Enfranchisement: Extending Complete Voting Rights in the U.S. Territories

In a series of cases stemming from the racist rationales of the Insular Cases, federal courts have created a doctrine that excludes territorial residents from federal elections, thus entrenching their political subordination. The courts have based their decisions on three main principles: First, because the constitutional provisions regarding federal elections refer only to states and are silent as to territories, territorial residents have no right to vote in federal elections. Second, because territorial residents are not a suspect class and do not have a fundamental right to vote, their disenfranchisement is subject to only rational basis review. Third, only statehood or a constitutional amendment can provide such a right. This Note challenges all three principles to provide a constitutional justification for equal enfranchisement.

Read More
Volume 113, February 2025, Justin Simard, Article California Law Review Volume 113, February 2025, Justin Simard, Article California Law Review

Slavery, Self-Help, and Secured Transactions

Section 9-609 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which has been enacted in every U.S. state, authorizes a secured lender to seize the property of a debtor in default without judicial process. The only limit to this power is that the lender cannot “breach the peace” in the process of repossession. This expansive right of self-help has spawned a $1.7 billion “asset recovery” industry in the United States that undertakes hundreds of thousands of repossessions every year. Many of these repossessions lead to violence. Lawyers, judges, and scholars justify the powerful right of self-help by pointing to its roots in the ancient common law right of recaption. The early cases they rely on, however, share little in common with the modern world of self-help repossession. This analysis also leaves out a more relevant history—the history of American slavery.

Read More