Articles, notes, and symposia pieces published in CLR’s print volumes.

Print Edition

Article, Volume 109, April 2021, Faiza W. Syed California Law Review Article, Volume 109, April 2021, Faiza W. Syed California Law Review

Terrorism and the Inherent Right to Self-Defense in Immigration Law

The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) deems an individual inadmissible to the United States for having engaged in terrorist activity. Both “engaged in terrorist activity” and “terrorist activity” are terms of art that are broadly defined under the INA to include activity that courts, scholars, and advocates agree stretches the definition of terrorism. An individual…

Read More
Note, Volume 109, April 2021, Virginia B. Lyon California Law Review Note, Volume 109, April 2021, Virginia B. Lyon California Law Review

The Means and the End: Understanding the Right to Vote as a Tool in Protecting the Right to Representation

The right to vote and the right to representation are often, to each of their detriment, conflated. But to combat voter disenfranchisement most effectively and honestly, we must conceive of these as two separate rights with a distinct relationship. Part I defines representative government. It then highlights the differences between the right to vote and…

Read More
Note, Volume 109, April 2021, Malka Herman California Law Review Note, Volume 109, April 2021, Malka Herman California Law Review

Creating a “Great Pro Bono Practice”

Pro bono at big law firms is often viewed as an altruistic way for attorneys to give back to society. But when big law firms partner with public interest law organizations (PILOs) to do pro bono work, conflicting interests among the parties involved may interfere with the aims of pro bono work. In this Note…

Read More
Note, Volume 109, February 2021, Madison Lo California Law Review Note, Volume 109, February 2021, Madison Lo California Law Review

A Domestic Violence Dystopia: Abuse via the Internet of Things and Remedies Under Current Law

Tactics of domestic violence are nothing new. However, as with various other aspects of modern life, technology threatens disruption. The increasing prevalence of Internet of Things (IoT) devices has given abusers a powerful new tool to expand and magnify the traditional harms of domestic violence, threatening the progress advocates have made in the past thirty…

Read More
Note, Volume 109, February 2021, Alexandra Zaretsky California Law Review Note, Volume 109, February 2021, Alexandra Zaretsky California Law Review

DNA Collection in Immigration Custody and the Threat of Genetic Surveillance

In October 2019, the Trump administration proposed a dramatic expansion of DNA collection from immigrants in federal detention. The final rule, which took effect in April 2020, eliminated a regulatory provision that had previously allowed the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to exempt noncitizens from DNA collection if collection was “not feasible because of…

Read More
Article, Volume 109, February 2021, Shelley Welton California Law Review Article, Volume 109, February 2021, Shelley Welton California Law Review

Rethinking Grid Governance for the Climate Change Era

The electricity sector is often appropriately called the linchpin of efforts to respond to climate change. Over the next few decades, the U.S. electricity sector will need to double in size to accommodate electric vehicles, while transforming to run entirely on clean energy. To drive this transformation, states are increasingly adopting 100 percent clean energy…

Read More
Article, Volume 109, February 2021, Suja A. Thomas California Law Review Article, Volume 109, February 2021, Suja A. Thomas California Law Review

The Customer Caste: Lawful Discrimination by Public Businesses

It is legal to follow and watch people in retail stores based on their race, give inferior service to restaurant customers based on their race, and place patrons in certain hotel rooms based on their race. Congress enacted Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to protect Black and other people of color…

Read More

Decolonizing Indigenous Migration

In this Article, we argue that accounting for the experience of Indigenous Peoples in the creation and regulation of borders is critical to advancing a human rights approach to migration and to addressing the legacies of conquest and colonization that undergird nation-state territorial sovereignty. By focusing on the unique situation of Indigenous Peoples, this Article…

Read More

Medical Professionals, Excessive Force, and the Fourth Amendment

Police use of force is a persistent problem in American cities, and the number of people killed at the hands of law enforcement has not decreased even as social movements raise greater awareness. This context has led to reform conversations on use of force that seek less violent ways for police to engage the public…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Shawn Trabanino California Law Review Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Shawn Trabanino California Law Review

Health, Law, And Ethnicity: The Disability Administrative Law Judge And Health Disparities For Disadvantaged Populations

Social determinants play into who gets to die prematurely while others get to have healthy productive lives—these are loosely called health disparities. Health disparities are typically understood socially, economically, and politically, but rarely analyzed within the legal system. The Social Security Administration (SSA)—the federal program for providing Americans with disabilities benefits and…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Kelly Seranko California Law Review Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Kelly Seranko California Law Review

What Happened to Full Faith and Credit?

In Franchise Tax Board v. Hyatt (Hyatt III), the Supreme Court overruled forty-year-old precedent that allowed a citizen to sue a state in another state’s courts. The Court’s 5–4 decision creates another barrier for plaintiffs who seek to hold states accountable. Hyatt III expands the doctrine of sovereign immunity to provide states additional protection against…

Read More
Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Abigail Burnam California Law Review Note, Volume 108, December 2020, Abigail Burnam California Law Review

Abortion Sanctuary Cities: A Local Response to The Criminalization of Self-Managed Abortion

You live in Mississippi, work an hourly, minimum wage job, have no savings, and have young children. You are also seven weeks pregnant and want to have an abortion. Technically, you can go to an abortion clinic. But even though you have Medicaid, it won’t cover any of the procedure’s costs because Mississippi generally follows…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Daphna Renan California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Daphna Renan California Law Review

“Institutional Settlement” in a Provisional Constitutional Order

I want to press a bit on the question of what the unwritten aspects of our constitutional structure establish. Rather than a fixed legal order constructed by conventions, I want to suggest that this unwrittenness points to the provisionality of the constitutional order itself—that is, to its essentially unsettled character. This perspective raises three problems…

Read More

Against Constitution by Convention

The Constitution emerged from a convention—a convention of the states. State popular conventions, by ratifying it, made it law. Though it was meant to “form a more perfect union,” no one could have supposed the Philadelphia Convention’s proposal was anything close to perfect. Indeed, the Constitution’s terms refute any blithe confidence in its flawlessness. Article…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Katherine Shaw California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 108, December 2020, Katherine Shaw California Law Review

Conventions in the Trenches

In this Essay, I identify several shifts in focus that might further illuminate the intersection of constitutional conventions and judicial review: first, attending to the role of internal executive-branch conventions, which are distinct in important ways from settlements between the political branches that are Issacharoff and Morrison’s primary focus; second, widening the lens to include…

Read More

Constitution by Convention

We are told that we live in the era of textualism. Inspired by the commanding presence of Justice Antonin Scalia, many accounts of American constitutional law focus on, and stress the preeminence of, the written word. On this view, the contractual sense of the constitution as a defined pact means that the intentionality of the original…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Erin Murphy, Jun H. Tong California Law Review Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Erin Murphy, Jun H. Tong California Law Review

The Racial Composition of Forensic DNA Databases

Forensic DNA databases have received an inordinate amount of academic and judicial attention. From their inception, numerous scholars, advocates, and judges have wrestled with the proper reach of DNA collection, retention, and search policies. Central to these debates are concerns about racial equity in forensic genetic practices. Yet when such questions arise, critics typically just…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Amna A. Akbar California Law Review Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Amna A. Akbar California Law Review

An Abolitionist Horizon for (Police) Reform

Since the Ferguson and Baltimore uprisings, legal scholarship has undergone a profound reckoning with police violence. The emerging structural account of police violence recognizes that it is routine, legal, takes many shapes, and targets people based on their race, class, and gender. But legal scholarship remains fixated on investing in the police to repair and…

Read More
Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Pooja R. Dadhania California Law Review Article, Volume 108, December 2020, Pooja R. Dadhania California Law Review

Paper Terrorists: Independence Movements and the Terrorism Bar

This Article explores the application of the terrorism bar in immigration law to noncitizens who have participated in an independence movement. It proposes a uniform standard that immigration adjudicators can use to determine whether a foreign entity is a state in order to promote accurate applications of the terrorism bar. The terrorism bar in the…

Read More

Does <em>Revlon</em> Matter? An Empirical and Theoretical Study

We empirically examine whether and how the doctrine of enhanced judicial scrutiny that emerged from Revlon and its progeny actually affects M&A transactions. Combining hand-coding and machine-learning techniques, we assemble data from the proxy statements of publicly announced mergers between 2003 and 2017 into a dataset of 1,913 unique transactions. Of these, 1,167 transactions were…

Read More