Articles, notes, and symposia pieces published in CLR’s print volumes.

Print Edition

Unaccompanied Minors, Statutory Interpretation, and Due Process

In recent years, there has been a massive influx of unaccompanied minors (UMs) crossing the southern border. Under the Trump administration, migrant children are being held in detention centers at unprecedented levels, with a five-fold increase in the last year alone. Without legal representation, UMs have little to no capability to defend against removal charges and to advocate for any existing statutory…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, David Alan Sklansky California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, David Alan Sklansky California Law Review

Populism, Pluralism, and Criminal Justice

The story that James Forman Jr. tells in his superb book, Locking Up Our Own, is local and nuanced. Forman explains that mass incarceration resulted from many small decisions made in many different places. Although all of those decisions were shaped by the legacies of racism and racial oppression, Forman shows that mass incarceration was…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, L. Song Richardson California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, L. Song Richardson California Law Review

The Fallacy of the (Racial) Solidarity Presumption

Mass incarceration in America is a story of race discrimination. On the one hand, this means our knowledge about discrimination helps explain why our criminal system looks the way it does. On the other hand, mass incarceration can also teach us something profound about the nature of discrimination itself. In Locking Up Our Own, James Forman Jr. does a masterful job excavating, analyzing…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, Paul Butler California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, Paul Butler California Law Review

Locking Up My Own: Reflections of a Black (Recovering) Prosecutor

I was a prosecutor in the District of Columbia during the era of Locking Up Our Own. I was a trial attorney in the U.S. Department of Justice in the early 1990s. Most of my work was in the Public Integrity Section at Main Justice, but for approximately one year I was detailed to the misdemeanor section of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia. The U.S. Attorney’s Office serves as the…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, Rachel E. Barkow California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, Rachel E. Barkow California Law Review

Three Lessons for Criminal Law Reformers

James Forman, Jr.’s Locking Up Our Own is that rare nonfiction work that is a page turner even when you know the ending. That is the product of exceptional writing, meticulous historical research, and the deep empathy of the author that gives the book its voice throughout. That is why it was both a worthy recipient the Pulitzer Prize and a feature on The Daily Show with Trevor Noah. It is as…

Read More
Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, James Forman California Law Review Symposium, Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, James Forman California Law Review

Confronting Mass Incarceration: Lecture from the 2018–2019 Jorde Symposium

Thank you. It’s a real honor to be at any event that is sponsored by the Brennan Center. I read your tweets, your emails, your policy reports, and your articles in the Atlantic. You are a vital institution. Thank you for doing the work that you are doing. I had a chance to spend some time with Tom Jorde earlier this afternoon, and Tom, I want to tell you how much I appreciate you putting your name…

Read More

Party Preferences in Multidistrict Litigation

Perhaps the two most salient trends in complex litigation have been the rise of multidistrict litigation (MDL) and the fall of aggregation on plaintiffs’ terms. According to recent statistics, more than one third of federal cases are consolidated within MDLs—meaning that they are being litigated before judges handpicked by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation…

Read More

Deep Fakes: A Looming Challenge for Privacy, Democracy, and National Security

Harmful lies are nothing new. But the ability to distort reality has taken an exponential leap forward with “deep fake” technology. This capability makes it possible to create audio and video of real people saying and doing things they never said or did. Machine learning techniques are escalating the technology’s sophistication, making deep fakes ever…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, December 2019, Isaac Ramsey California Law Review Note, Volume 107, December 2019, Isaac Ramsey California Law Review

Hidden Renvoi: The Search for Corporate Liability in Alien Tort Statute Litigation

In its two most recent decisions regarding the Alien Tort Statute (ATS)—Jesner v. Arab Bank and Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum—the US Supreme Court failed to answer the specific question upon which it granted certiorari: whether the ATS permits suit against corporate defendants. These two cases reveal only that the ATS does not permit suits…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, December 2019, Brady Williams California Law Review Note, Volume 107, December 2019, Brady Williams California Law Review

Unconscionability as a Sword: The Case for an Affirmative Cause of Action

Consumers are drowning in a sea of one-sided fine print. To combat contractual overreach, consumers need an arsenal of effective remedies. To that end, the doctrine of unconscionability provides a crucial defense against the inequities of rigid contract enforcement. However, the prevailing view that unconscionability operates merely as a “shield” and not a “sword” leaves…

Read More
Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, Daniel Farbman California Law Review Essay, Volume 107, December 2019, Daniel Farbman California Law Review

Resistance Lawyering

This is the story of a group of abolitionist lawyers who devoted themselves to working within a legal system that they considered to be fundamentally unjust and illegitimate. These “resistance lawyers” used the limited and unfriendly procedural tools of the hated Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 to frustrate, oppose, and, if possible, dismantle the operation…

Read More

After Janus

The Supreme Court in Janus v. American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, Council 31 upended public sector labor law by finding a novel First Amendment right of public employees to refuse to pay union fees and declaring unconstitutional scores of laws and thousands of labor contracts. This Article assesses the constraints on public…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, October 2019, Sarah M. Lakhani California Law Review Note, Volume 107, October 2019, Sarah M. Lakhani California Law Review

Universalizing the U Visa: Challenges of Immigration Case Selection in Legal Nonprofits

The resource limitations of legal nonprofit organizations force staff attorneys to make difficult choices about whom to serve. Nowhere are the consequences of lawyers’ case selection decisions starker than in the immigration context, where individuals face deportation if unable to successfully advocate for themselves before legal authorities. Based on three years of qualitative research within…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, October 2019, Miriam Elnemr Rofael California Law Review Note, Volume 107, October 2019, Miriam Elnemr Rofael California Law Review

Improving the Housing Choice Voucher Program through Source of Income Discrimination Laws

The Housing Choice Voucher (“HCV”) program is a government program that subsidizes the rent of low-income individuals or families, allowing them to afford housing in the private market. Families pay 30 percent of their income towards rent, and the voucher covers the remainder. Congress created the program with the goal of enabling low-income families to…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, October 2019, Daniel Yablon California Law Review Note, Volume 107, October 2019, Daniel Yablon California Law Review

Proximate Cause in Statutory Standing and the Genesis of Federal Common Law

The federal courts have long struggled to articulate a set of coherent standards for who may assert rights under a federal statute. Apart from the constitutional limitations of the judicial power under Article III, courts have until recently addressed this question under a series of freestanding “prudential” rules governing standing to sue. The Supreme Court’s…

Read More
Article, Volume 107, October 2019, Jessica A. Shoemaker California Law Review Article, Volume 107, October 2019, Jessica A. Shoemaker California Law Review

Transforming Property: Reclaiming Indigenous Land Tenures

This Article challenges existing narratives about the future of American Indian land tenure. The current highly-federalized system for reservation property is deeply problematic. In particular, the trust status of many reservation lands is expensive, bureaucratic, oppressive, and linked to persistent poverty in many reservation communities. Yet, for complex reasons, trust property has proven…

Read More
Article, Volume 107, October 2019, Amy Adler, Jeanne C. Fromer California Law Review Article, Volume 107, October 2019, Amy Adler, Jeanne C. Fromer California Law Review

Taking Intellectual Property into Their Own Hands

When we think about people seeking relief for infringement of their intellectual property rights under copyright and trademark laws, we typically assume they will operate within an overtly legal scheme. By contrast, creators of works that lie outside the subject matter, or at least outside the heartland, of intellectual property law often remedy copying of…

Read More
Paper, Volume 107, October 2019, Darryl K. Brown California Law Review Paper, Volume 107, October 2019, Darryl K. Brown California Law Review

The Case for a Trial Fee: What Money Can Buy in Criminal Process

Money motivates and regulates criminal process. Conscious of adjudication costs, prosecutors incentivize guilty pleas with the prospect of a “trial penalty”: harsher post-trial sentences. Budgetary considerations motivate revenue-generating enforcement policies and asset forfeitures by law enforcement. States also charge defendants directly for nearly every criminal justice expense…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, August 2019, Andrew Schmidt California Law Review Note, Volume 107, August 2019, Andrew Schmidt California Law Review

Pump the Brakes: What Financial Regulators Should Consider in Trying to Prevent a Subprime Auto Loan Bubble

The possibility of a subprime auto finance bubble gives financial regulators an opportunity to navigate a burgeoning crisis in real time. Lessons learned from the 2008 financial crisis and the implementation of the Dodd-Frank Act prompt the question whether financial regulators should adopt an ability-to-repay rule for auto lending similar to the Consumer Financial Protection…

Read More
Note, Volume 107, August 2019, Drew C. Schaefer California Law Review Note, Volume 107, August 2019, Drew C. Schaefer California Law Review

Applying the SEC Custody Rule to Cryptocurrency Hedge Fund Managers

In the wake of the Bernard Madoff Ponzi scheme, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adjusted its rules to prevent future fraud. Despite blindsiding the SEC and many in the financial industry, the culprit was all too familiar: a bad adviser fleecing his trusting clients. The problem goes back millennia. In 1754 B.C…

Read More